diff --git a/src/components/appRouter.js b/src/components/appRouter.js
index dd350542a6..5b0d61ab3a 100644
--- a/src/components/appRouter.js
+++ b/src/components/appRouter.js
@@ -757,13 +757,7 @@ class AppRouter {
         }
 
         if (item === 'nextup') {
-            url = '#!/list.html?type=nextup&serverId=' + options.serverId;
-
-            if (options.rewatching) {
-                url += '&rewatching=' + options.rewatching;
-            }
-
-            return url;
+            return '#!/list.html?type=nextup&serverId=' + options.serverId;
         }
 
         if (item === 'list') {
diff --git a/src/components/displaySettings/displaySettings.js b/src/components/displaySettings/displaySettings.js
index 8951eae1c4..bf93e7a005 100644
--- a/src/components/displaySettings/displaySettings.js
+++ b/src/components/displaySettings/displaySettings.js
@@ -113,7 +113,6 @@ import template from './displaySettings.template.html';
         context.querySelector('#chkBlurhash').checked = userSettings.enableBlurhash();
         context.querySelector('#chkBackdrops').checked = userSettings.enableBackdrops();
         context.querySelector('#chkDetailsBanner').checked = userSettings.detailsBanner();
-        context.querySelector('#chkUseEpisodeImagesInNextUp').checked = userSettings.useEpisodeImagesInNextUpAndResume();
 
         context.querySelector('#chkDisableCustomCss').checked = userSettings.disableCustomCss();
         context.querySelector('#txtLocalCustomCss').value = userSettings.customCss();
@@ -122,7 +121,10 @@ import template from './displaySettings.template.html';
         context.querySelector('.selectDateTimeLocale').value = userSettings.dateTimeLocale() || '';
 
         context.querySelector('#txtLibraryPageSize').value = userSettings.libraryPageSize();
+
         context.querySelector('#txtMaxDaysForNextUp').value = userSettings.maxDaysForNextUp();
+        context.querySelector('#chkRewatchingNextUp').checked = userSettings.enableRewatchingInNextUp();
+        context.querySelector('#chkUseEpisodeImagesInNextUp').checked = userSettings.useEpisodeImagesInNextUpAndResume();
 
         context.querySelector('.selectLayout').value = layoutManager.getSavedLayout() || '';
 
@@ -147,13 +149,15 @@ import template from './displaySettings.template.html';
         userSettingsInstance.screensaver(context.querySelector('.selectScreensaver').value);
 
         userSettingsInstance.libraryPageSize(context.querySelector('#txtLibraryPageSize').value);
+
         userSettingsInstance.maxDaysForNextUp(context.querySelector('#txtMaxDaysForNextUp').value);
+        userSettingsInstance.enableRewatchingInNextUp(context.querySelector('#chkRewatchingNextUp').checked);
+        userSettingsInstance.useEpisodeImagesInNextUpAndResume(context.querySelector('#chkUseEpisodeImagesInNextUp').checked);
 
         userSettingsInstance.enableFastFadein(context.querySelector('#chkFadein').checked);
         userSettingsInstance.enableBlurhash(context.querySelector('#chkBlurhash').checked);
         userSettingsInstance.enableBackdrops(context.querySelector('#chkBackdrops').checked);
         userSettingsInstance.detailsBanner(context.querySelector('#chkDetailsBanner').checked);
-        userSettingsInstance.useEpisodeImagesInNextUpAndResume(context.querySelector('#chkUseEpisodeImagesInNextUp').checked);
 
         userSettingsInstance.disableCustomCss(context.querySelector('#chkDisableCustomCss').checked);
         userSettingsInstance.customCss(context.querySelector('#txtLocalCustomCss').value);
diff --git a/src/components/displaySettings/displaySettings.template.html b/src/components/displaySettings/displaySettings.template.html
index 9fb73c77cb..1f6685f333 100644
--- a/src/components/displaySettings/displaySettings.template.html
+++ b/src/components/displaySettings/displaySettings.template.html
@@ -207,6 +207,14 @@
         <div class="fieldDescription">${LabelMaxDaysForNextUpHelp}</div>
     </div>
 
+    <div class="checkboxContainer checkboxContainer-withDescription">
+        <label>
+            <input type="checkbox" is="emby-checkbox" id="chkRewatchingNextUp" />
+            <span>${EnableRewatchingNextUp}</span>
+        </label>
+        <div class="fieldDescription checkboxFieldDescription">${EnableRewatchingNextUpHelp}</div>
+    </div>
+
     <div class="checkboxContainer checkboxContainer-withDescription">
         <label>
             <input type="checkbox" is="emby-checkbox" id="chkFadein" />
diff --git a/src/components/homeScreenSettings/homeScreenSettings.template.html b/src/components/homeScreenSettings/homeScreenSettings.template.html
index 2ecb1cea5e..d3a9206c33 100644
--- a/src/components/homeScreenSettings/homeScreenSettings.template.html
+++ b/src/components/homeScreenSettings/homeScreenSettings.template.html
@@ -27,7 +27,6 @@
                 <option value="resumebook">${HeaderContinueReading}</option>
                 <option value="latestmedia">${HeaderLatestMedia}</option>
                 <option value="nextup">${NextUp}</option>
-                <option value="rewatching">${NextUpRewatching}</option>
                 <option value="livetv">${LiveTV}</option>
                 <option value="none">${None}</option>
             </select>
@@ -42,7 +41,6 @@
                 <option value="resumebook">${HeaderContinueReading}</option>
                 <option value="latestmedia">${HeaderLatestMedia}</option>
                 <option value="nextup">${NextUp}</option>
-                <option value="rewatching">${NextUpRewatching}</option>
                 <option value="livetv">${LiveTV}</option>
                 <option value="none">${None}</option>
             </select>
@@ -57,7 +55,6 @@
                 <option value="resumebook">${HeaderContinueReading}</option>
                 <option value="latestmedia">${HeaderLatestMedia}</option>
                 <option value="nextup">${NextUp}</option>
-                <option value="rewatching">${NextUpRewatching}</option>
                 <option value="livetv">${LiveTV}</option>
                 <option value="none">${None}</option>
             </select>
@@ -72,7 +69,6 @@
                 <option value="resumebook">${HeaderContinueReading}</option>
                 <option value="latestmedia">${HeaderLatestMedia}</option>
                 <option value="nextup">${NextUp}</option>
-                <option value="rewatching">${NextUpRewatching}</option>
                 <option value="livetv">${LiveTV}</option>
                 <option value="none">${None}</option>
             </select>
@@ -87,7 +83,6 @@
                 <option value="resumebook">${HeaderContinueReading}</option>
                 <option value="latestmedia">${HeaderLatestMedia}</option>
                 <option value="nextup">${NextUp}</option>
-                <option value="rewatching">${NextUpRewatching}</option>
                 <option value="livetv">${LiveTV}</option>
                 <option value="none">${None}</option>
             </select>
@@ -102,7 +97,6 @@
                 <option value="resumebook">${HeaderContinueReading}</option>
                 <option value="latestmedia">${HeaderLatestMedia}</option>
                 <option value="nextup">${NextUp}</option>
-                <option value="rewatching">${NextUpRewatching}</option>
                 <option value="livetv">${LiveTV}</option>
                 <option value="none">${None}</option>
             </select>
@@ -117,7 +111,6 @@
                 <option value="resumebook">${HeaderContinueReading}</option>
                 <option value="latestmedia">${HeaderLatestMedia}</option>
                 <option value="nextup">${NextUp}</option>
-                <option value="rewatching">${NextUpRewatching}</option>
                 <option value="livetv">${LiveTV}</option>
                 <option value="none">${None}</option>
             </select>
diff --git a/src/components/homesections/homesections.js b/src/components/homesections/homesections.js
index 5926fb5b4b..25c231d560 100644
--- a/src/components/homesections/homesections.js
+++ b/src/components/homesections/homesections.js
@@ -147,8 +147,6 @@ import ServerConnections from '../ServerConnections';
             loadLatestLiveTvRecordings(elem, true, apiClient);
         } else if (section === 'nextup') {
             loadNextUp(elem, apiClient, userSettings);
-        } else if (section === 'rewatching') {
-            loadNextUp(elem, apiClient, userSettings, true);
         } else if (section === 'onnow' || section === 'livetv') {
             return loadOnNow(elem, apiClient, user);
         } else if (section === 'resumebook') {
@@ -598,7 +596,7 @@ import ServerConnections from '../ServerConnections';
         });
     }
 
-    function getNextUpFetchFn(serverId, userSettings, rewatching) {
+    function getNextUpFetchFn(serverId, userSettings) {
         return function () {
             const apiClient = ServerConnections.getApiClient(serverId);
             const oldestDateForNextUp = new Date();
@@ -612,7 +610,7 @@ import ServerConnections from '../ServerConnections';
                 EnableTotalRecordCount: false,
                 DisableFirstEpisode: false,
                 NextUpDateCutoff: oldestDateForNextUp.toISOString(),
-                Rewatching: rewatching
+                EnableRewatching: userSettings.enableRewatchingInNextUp()
             });
         };
     }
@@ -638,31 +636,22 @@ import ServerConnections from '../ServerConnections';
         };
     }
 
-    function loadNextUp(elem, apiClient, userSettings, rewatching = false) {
+    function loadNextUp(elem, apiClient, userSettings) {
         let html = '';
 
         html += '<div class="sectionTitleContainer sectionTitleContainer-cards padded-left">';
         if (!layoutManager.tv) {
             html += '<a is="emby-linkbutton" href="' + appRouter.getRouteUrl('nextup', {
-                serverId: apiClient.serverId(),
-                rewatching: rewatching
+                serverId: apiClient.serverId()
             }) + '" class="button-flat button-flat-mini sectionTitleTextButton">';
             html += '<h2 class="sectionTitle sectionTitle-cards">';
-            if (rewatching) {
-                html += globalize.translate('NextUpRewatching');
-            } else {
-                html += globalize.translate('NextUp');
-            }
+            html += globalize.translate('NextUp');
             html += '</h2>';
             html += '<span class="material-icons chevron_right" aria-hidden="true"></span>';
             html += '</a>';
         } else {
             html += '<h2 class="sectionTitle sectionTitle-cards">';
-            if (rewatching) {
-                html += globalize.translate('NextUpRewatching');
-            } else {
-                html += globalize.translate('NextUp');
-            }
+            html += globalize.translate('NextUp');
             html += '</h2>';
         }
         html += '</div>';
@@ -683,7 +672,7 @@ import ServerConnections from '../ServerConnections';
         elem.innerHTML = html;
 
         const itemsContainer = elem.querySelector('.itemsContainer');
-        itemsContainer.fetchData = getNextUpFetchFn(apiClient.serverId(), userSettings, rewatching);
+        itemsContainer.fetchData = getNextUpFetchFn(apiClient.serverId(), userSettings);
         itemsContainer.getItemsHtml = getNextUpItemsHtmlFn(userSettings.useEpisodeImagesInNextUpAndResume());
         itemsContainer.parentContainer = elem;
     }
diff --git a/src/controllers/list.js b/src/controllers/list.js
index 68cf09fe31..105817605b 100644
--- a/src/controllers/list.js
+++ b/src/controllers/list.js
@@ -260,7 +260,7 @@ import { appRouter } from '../components/appRouter';
                 EnableImageTypes: 'Primary,Backdrop,Thumb',
                 EnableTotalRecordCount: false,
                 SortBy: sortBy,
-                Rewatching: params.rewatching
+                EnableRewatching: userSettings.enableRewatchingInNextUp()
             }));
         }
 
@@ -678,9 +678,6 @@ class ItemsView {
             }
 
             if (params.type === 'nextup') {
-                if (params.rewatching === 'true') {
-                    return globalize.translate('NextUpRewatching');
-                }
                 return globalize.translate('NextUp');
             }
 
diff --git a/src/scripts/settings/userSettings.js b/src/scripts/settings/userSettings.js
index 6a1dadde1a..b581ad310e 100644
--- a/src/scripts/settings/userSettings.js
+++ b/src/scripts/settings/userSettings.js
@@ -458,6 +458,19 @@ export class UserSettings {
         }
     }
 
+    /**
+     * Get or set rewatching in next up.
+     * @param {boolean|undefined} val - If rewatching items should be included in next up.
+     * @returns {boolean} Rewatching in next up state.
+     */
+    enableRewatchingInNextUp(val) {
+        if (val !== undefined) {
+            return this.set('enableRewatchingInNextUp', val, false);
+        }
+
+        return this.get('enableRewatchingInNextUp', false);
+    }
+
     /**
      * Get or set sound effects.
      * @param {string|undefined} val - Sound effects.
@@ -576,6 +589,7 @@ export const theme = currentSettings.theme.bind(currentSettings);
 export const screensaver = currentSettings.screensaver.bind(currentSettings);
 export const libraryPageSize = currentSettings.libraryPageSize.bind(currentSettings);
 export const maxDaysForNextUp = currentSettings.maxDaysForNextUp.bind(currentSettings);
+export const enableRewatchingInNextUp = currentSettings.enableRewatchingInNextUp.bind(currentSettings);
 export const soundEffects = currentSettings.soundEffects.bind(currentSettings);
 export const loadQuerySettings = currentSettings.loadQuerySettings.bind(currentSettings);
 export const saveQuerySettings = currentSettings.saveQuerySettings.bind(currentSettings);
diff --git a/src/strings/en-us.json b/src/strings/en-us.json
index d288e74cdf..759bc96713 100644
--- a/src/strings/en-us.json
+++ b/src/strings/en-us.json
@@ -235,6 +235,8 @@
     "EnableNextVideoInfoOverlayHelp": "At the end of a video, display info about the next video coming up in the current playlist.",
     "EnablePhotos": "Display the photos",
     "EnablePhotosHelp": "Images will be detected and displayed alongside other media files.",
+    "EnableRewatchingNextUp": "Enable Rewatching in Next Up",
+    "EnableRewatchingNextUpHelp": "Enable showing already watched episodes in 'Next Up' sections.",
     "EnableQuickConnect": "Enable Quick Connect on this server",
     "EnableStreamLooping": "Auto-loop live streams",
     "EnableStreamLoopingHelp": "Enable this if live streams only contain a few seconds of data and need to be continuously requested. Enabling this when not needed may cause problems.",
@@ -1135,7 +1137,6 @@
     "NextChapter": "Next chapter",
     "NextTrack": "Skip to next",
     "NextUp": "Next Up",
-    "NextUpRewatching": "Rewatching",
     "No": "No",
     "NoCreatedLibraries": "Seems like you haven't created any libraries yet. {0}Would you like to create one now?{1}",
     "None": "None",